Loading...
CC - 06-02-90 - Adjourned Meeting0 • APPROVED MINUTES OF AN ADJOURNED MEETING CITY OF ROSEMEAD ROSEMEAD CITY COUNCIL DATE 7"/0- 90 JUNE 2, 1990 BY_Z o~ The Adjourned Meeting of the Rosemead City Council was called to order by Mayor McDonald at 9:07 a.m. in the conference Room of City Hall, 8838 E. Valley Boulevard, Rosemead, California. The Pledge to the Flag was led by Mayor McDonald and the Invocation was delivered by Councilman Bruesch. ROLL CALL OF OFFICERS: Present: Councilmen Bruesch, Imperial, Taylor, and Mayor McDonald Absent: Mayor Pro Tem DeCocker - Excused ROSEMEAD BOYS & GIRLS CLUB - 01-4200-730 VERBATIM DIALOGUE FOLLOWS: FRANK G. TRIPEPI, CITY MANAGER: The amount requested for fiscal year 90-91, Mr. Mayor and Councilmembers, is $25,000. MCDONALD: Would you like to make a little presentation, Mr. Robles, and tell us why you'd like that money and what you're going to use it for? ANTHONY ROBLES, PRESIDENT: First of all, we'd like to have that money like we had last year to follow up on programs that we are continuing from the past year. The organization has been reorganizing itself as you all know with losing of our Executive Director and our plans of getting a new Director and putting it more on the Board's shoulders to make the club more accountable and run like a business more efficiently which I think we have successfully done. Also, I've got some good news in the fact that we've gone through quite a bit, substantial interviews, and we've made a decision to offer a position to an individual that we think would be very good for our Club so that it should be happening within the next two to three weeks. We also ran a feasibility study this past year to see where we were at and the possibility of growth for our Club, fund-raising and so on so that we don't have to always to_rely on the City funds and some other funds that we have been getting. So, that has looked very successful. The kids that we have been serving in the past year are very needy kids. We've got a couple of other programs going with Juvenile Diversion. We've got some people coming in from Help Club that are running a program that are trying to help out on that end of it and we've established a parents' club so we're trying to get the parents involved with the kids down there, because as you know, that area, there is a real problem down there with getting the parents involved with the kids that come to the Club. We've also established a merchant group down there where we've got them getting involved with the kids at the Club and donating some of their time and money. So, I personally think the Board is pushing towards a very more businesslike for the Club and we're looking a lot stronger. Financially wise, we're well on the black with the Club. As of yesterday, we're up around $14,000 in the black. All the financial parts, the taxes, have been taken care of. The Club's run a lot more efficient this year. Hopefully it will run a lot better next year. McDONALD: Do you have an annual audit done? ROBLES: We haven't had process right now. We' we're getting estimates went through our United them that by the end of that finished, too. an independent audit done. ie gotten about four people for on what that's going t, Way audit and we have made June or first part of July We're in the right now that 3 cost us. We just a commitment to that we should have McDONALD: Have you been assessed by United Way already this year? ROBLES: Yes. McDONALD: How much did we pay them last year? ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #1 • TRIPEPI: $18,300. 0 ROBLES: It was only $18,300?- I thought it was $25,000. TAYLOR: The appropriation was for $25,000. TRIPEPI: The actual dollars. I don't think you got started right away. You had some problems with that and getting everything so that $18,300 doesn't represent a full fiscal year, Mr. Mayor. That's just actual dollars. McDONALD: Any other questions from Council? IMPERIAL: I have a question. If this money is appropriated, that doesn't mean that it necessarily has to go to the Boys Club, am I correct? McDONALD: Do we pay them on a monthly basis? TRIPEPI: Yes, paid on a monthly. IMPERIAL: The reason I'm asking this question some information and I haven't received it yet. for the appropriation but not for the Boys Club I've received my answers and I'm satisfied with hold it up maybe we can vote to appropriate the make sure that doesn't mean we're going to give overruled. Ls that I've asked for I am prepared to vote to get the money until them. So, if it would money but I want to the money unless I'm McDONALD: Mr. City Attorney, you want to answer that? Can we tie up something like that? ROBERT KRESS, CITY ATTORNEY: Well, this is really just planning for the expenditure. The payment of the funds is controlled by the contract that you have with the Boys & Girls Club which I believe is subject to annual renewal. So that really controls the actual invoicing and payment of money. This budget process is planning for the overall needs of the City and making a reservation on that amount of money. McDONALD: It's like when we adopt the budget we adopt those as a projected thing and we revote the expenditures. TRIPEPI: Most of it you appropriate at the Council meeting, at the warrant register. They don't get a $25,000 check at the beginning of the fiscal year. McDONALD: We appropriate the monies and then we...? IMPERIAL: Can we just hold this over until I get my information? TAYLOR: I would agree with that. If you've asked for it and haven't got itland I want to see the budget actual expenditure for this year and next year's. McDONALD: Mr. Robleslit appears that we have a consensus to approve the appropriation and as soon as we get the information we can follow through on it. IMPERIAL: I don't think that..... McDONALD: We can table it? How would you do that? KRESS: Just defer action. McDONALD: We'll just defer action on the Rosemead Boys & Girls Club. ROBLES: Can you spell exactly what you want out and I'll get it back to you? IMPERIAL: I wanted a budget. I want a list of all activities that have taken place. I just a whole breakdown on the organization so I can be satisfied and I'm not saying that you're not telling me the truth, okay? ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #2 • 0 ROBLES: No, I understand. That's no problem. IMPERIAL: Mr. Robles, I've sat through a few of these and Gary has, too. We haven't always gotten what we've been told. I want you to understand and I want the record to show that my feeling for the concept of a Boys Club is outstanding. I spent most of my young life in one, okay? But I don't feel like in the past things have been proper and, therefore, I want that information before I make a decision with the taxpayer's money. ROBLES: That's good. I appreciate you letting me know this because as the Board President of the Rosemead Boys & Girls Club we're in the same wavelength as you are. We want to make sure that everybody sees that what we're doing is very well organized and that we're giving things that are asked for. This is the first time I've heard that you wanted these things but there's no problem about it. We'll get it for you. McDONALD: We apologize for that. He must have talked to another boardmember. IMPERIAL: I talked to a boardmember and haven't received it yet. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. I'd like to make a comment to Mr. Robles, also, that my opinions and the information that I ask for reflects on no individual. It's a procedure-. We have five other organizations on here, new ones started last year.and this year, $100,000 beyond what you're asking for. The dollars aren't really the issue as far as I'm concerned any more, it's just the way that they explode and there's another ten organizations in the City that are entitled to the money. It's just like, and again it's no reflection on the Boys Club. It's just that common practice that well, we will go the government for more money. And that's all the agencies. So, that's ...I can explain that later. ROBLES: I understand that. I can give you, when I bring you the budget of this year and next year and show you the budgets from the past couple of years, you'll see the growth that the Rosemead Boys & Girls Club had and I think you'll feel confident..... TAYLOR: Well, like I say, it's no reflection on the Boys Club, it's just something that's going on all over, not just Rosemead but it gets to be overwhelming and you know on the news they're looking every which way how do we get more taxes? President Bush, the State government, the County, we've got to get more, we've got to get more. And it's not the idea of the money it's what do they need the money for. What's happening that all this is coming about. ROBLES: Don't worry. I understand. We'll get all that stuff for you. MCDONALD: We apologize for not having told you prior to this time what information we needed. Do you understand what they want then? ROBLES: Sure. McDONALD: Thank you very much for coming in. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. I'd like my comment in the minutes verbatim because it's going to reflect through all of these. ASIAN PACIFIC FAMILY CENTER - 01-4200-745 VERBATIM DIALOGUE CONTINUES: McDONALD: We have here Gladys Lee, the Director of the Asian Pacific Family Center who would like to make her presentation. TRIPEPI: Her request this morning is for $42,000 and I believe that this the reason that this request has come in from Asian Family Center is due to the basically the cancelling of the Ingleside contract by the hospital itself. I know that Gladys is familiar with Ingleside ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #3 • • TRIPEPI CONTINUES: and she heard that they were no longer going to provide the service for $42,000 or whatever they were receiving at that time. She's put together a budget for the Council's consideration this morning. With that.... McDONALD: We gave to Ingleside prior to last year how much money on an annual basis? TRIPEPI: $42,000. McDONALD: It was $42,000? And they are not now providing that service at all. TRIPEPI: They sent a letter which we provided to the Council. They're not interested in doing the service. McDONALD: All right, Gladys, would you like to explain what you have to offer us? GLADYS LEE, DIRECTOR, ASIAN PACIFIC FAMILY CENTER: Okay. We have been in the community, specifically in the City of Rosemead, for a little over four years, now. And we're primarily funded by Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health and recently got a little bit of money from Department of Children Services. We do child abuse, we do a little bit of gang prevention but specifically we're here today to ask for your support in providing services to the youth in the City of Rosemead. In the last four years we've been quite successful in working mostly with the Alhambra School District in the form of intercultural discussion groups where we go in, take kids from different ethnic backgrounds, put them together in groups for about ten weeks and kind of provide a safe environment for them to relate to each other and share some common concerns and also reduce some of the racial tension on campus. We've graduated close to 500 students now and it's been a very successful program specifically at Mark Keppel High School. We've also in the last two years developed a crisis drop-in center that's now going on at San Gabriel High, Alhambra High and will begin at Mark Keppel High that we'd like to bring to Rosemead High and basically we outstation our staff on campus. We get to know the school counselors, the security person, the student leaders, and students just confidentially drop in to see us. In the last year those of you who were at our dinner, the young man who spoke was one of the students that we interfaced at the crisis drop-in center, initially. What we do is try to diffuse the crisis, talk them into other alternatives, and if the problems are more severe we bring them into the Center for direct treatment services. The problems range from truancy, running away, to depression, to suicides. There are some very serious problems. We also have developed using a rational emotive model a skilled development group, mostly kids who are referred by Juvenile Diversion, kids who are picked up for petty theft or on the verge of getting into pre-criminal activities where we put them together again and teach them how their attitudes and the way they look at things is influencing their feelings which is then influencing their behavior. So, we're also proposing to offer a series of skilled development groups, mostly.on the elementary and intermediate level, junior high level because once they get to high school those who have problems, this kind of group would not be affective with them. Finally, we want to also do some case management information referral. We just got a letter for instance from the Muscatel School about a Cambodian kid that the principal is very concerned about, that he's going to get into some kind of gang activities if he's not diverted. we could not meet the request because our staff right now is so overloaded with people who are suicidal, who are extremely depressed, we cannot respond to a community request such as this. So, information referral case management would offer us the resource to go to where the family is or where the kid is, try to connect them with resource that would prevent such kind of gang involvement. We also offered to provide community education and consultation to five agencies in the City of Rosemead that requires maybe a better understanding of how to work with the Asian family. We'd like to work closer with the Rosemead Boys & Girls Club, interface with them, help them advertise or you know like they have some camp programs with the Asian community, offer ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page 44 • LEE CONTINUES: consultation to City. One of the things that we awareness and how to outreach to appreciate this opportunity. PJ some local schools and even to the do quite well is also cultural the Asian community. So, I very much McDONALD: We're responsible to see that the dollars that we collect here in Rosemead are spent here in Rosemead. How would you log all that to show that if we do in fact appropriate the monies to your services how would you be able to tell us that you're servicing specifically Rosemead individuals? LEE: We can develop forms. Like we have three grants in our Center and each grant has different colored folders and each child has a preliminary intake form with address and City of residence. We would develop a system like that whereby if you wish a quarterly report we can give you a quarterly report of what we've done, the residence of the youths so that you can be assured that the services are delivered within the City. IMPERIAL: Mr. Mayor. I have a lot of questions in my mind about this. Gladys, you service the Asian community. IMPERIAL: We also have an organization that services the Hispanic community. My concern is what the percentage of Asians are that live in the City of Rosemead that you handle versus how much money you're asking for and I would feel the same way about any other agency that comes in here. I think we need this information before I myself could vote for it. LEE- Right. McDONALD: I think she's made the point fairly clear that she's not totally servicing the people in Rosemead because she does not have the funds to be able to do that. LEE: Well, let me add that I did a study on our intakes. We do about 250-300 intakes a year. Monterey Park, of course, is the highest city of intakes and Rosemead is the second. Now, in terms of numbers I don't have it with me today but we do serve a lot of people from Rosemead by the virtue of the fact that we're in the City of Rosemead but because we're primarily funded by Mental Health if you're not schizophrenic, if you're not on the verge of needing to be hospitalized, you're not acutely suicidal, we cannot serve anyone because they don't meet the County requirements anymore. They're defining the target population stricter and stricter and stricter as their resources dwindle. So,, our proposal is to serve the youth in Rosemead and it's not just the Asian youth, like an intercultural discussion group in the past four years, it's a mixture of Hispanic youth and Asian youth and Caucasian youth because we want to. mix the kids together so they can understand each other as kids rather than you're yellow, I'm brown and you're white and it's been a very successful program. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. Where can we get the actual statistics of juvenile or youth suicides for Monterey Park, Rosemead and such? They must have that listed somewhere. LEE: No, they don't. We've talked to police departments. No one keeps statistics. There are.... TAYLOR: How about the National Institute, they have poisonings, they list almost every death that's reported. There's a Federal agency that reports that, per state, per county, per city. LEE: A lot of suicides among youths are not reported. TAYLOR: There's got to be something on the death certificate even if they're dying and we'll have to make a rational guess. If there's no statistics then nobody can back it up on either side but there's got to be some kind of a death record. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #5 • • LEE: The kids that we deal with are the kids who attempt to commit suicide. They're not successful at it because they're still alive. But they attempt to overdose on aspirin or alcohol. They do things that would potentially hurt themselves. These are never reported. As a matter of fact in the intercultural group at Mark Keppel High School the teachers didn't even know that. It's true that in discussion groups that kids started telling us that two years ago I tried to slash my wrists but I didn't tell anyone. Those things would not be reflected in any public record because no one knows about them. IMPERIAL: Mr. Mayor. I think in answer to your question, Gary, if the Los Angeles County PET program would have the most up to date statistics on that and if we can request from the PET program those statistics we can get a better feel on it. KRESS: What are the initials? IMPERIAL: P-E-T, PET, they work out of Los Angeles County and they deal mainly with people that are suicidal, drug addicts and what have you and I think they keep statistics on them all. LEE: But I'd like to emphasize again that the kids that we are targeting are kids who are.... you know a lot of kids get in trouble and attempt suicide without even the parents knowing about it and it will not be on public record that if this Council uses this data to determine whether this program is viable or the needs are there then you will not find the data to.... McDONALD: If we fund your services you're not just offering us acute medical? LEE: No, no. This is intervention. The County will fund the acute. I'm not saying this program is going to serve the kids who are suicidal. This is a prevention program. BRUESCH: Mr. Mayor. I've had experience with kids at our school that, the Asian kids who are in this pre-stage, before the restrictions were put on there was some service and the problem is a lot of Asian families don't go through the normal steps of intervention services because most of the time they will not come to a counseling program or a parent program because of the cultural differences. They will not avail themselves of the normal services and what is needed is actually home visits from the counseling system which most counseling systems do not have the facilities to provide and a lot of these kids who are coming out of seventh and eighth grade and going into the Asian gangs have been earmarked as potential at-risk kids for four or five years but because the families would not avail themselves of the normal type of counseling programs that are offered by the schools the kids go unserved and I've seen this time and time again and there is a special need for those type of kids. I just had one kid that was a constant runaway that it took us three years to get service and only through Asian counseling was the family finally convinced that the kid had problems, was removed from the home and placed in a halfway house and this comes up time and time again. There is a unique need out there. McDONALD: What kind of service could you provide for half that money? LEE: Half the service. McDONALD: Half the service. We have a population in this City of probably 50% or 60% Hispanic and almost 30% Asian. Ingleside provided that service blankly to everybody, didn't have a tag on it or had a perception to it. The Asian Pacific Family Center has an Asian perception to it and somebody else who is on the agenda, the Family Counseling Service, is more Hispanic-based. We have given out the $42,000 in years past on statistics that Intervale gave to us that we thought were justified. If we now, like I said we have two organizations that are asking for the amount that Intervale has and it looks as though, perception-wise, that they would be only serving a portion of those people if we gave them that money. You could give us half the service for $21,000. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #6 LEE: Yes, and I know Roberta very well. I'd be happy to work closer with her, especially in the way that early intervention many times you see kids who need direct treatment services. We don't have the specialty that the Family Counseling has with the Hispanic population and we can mutually refer to each other. But with this kind of case management service we can go into the home, we can go and connect these kids with resources out there that may not just be mental health and what we're finding is once a week family therapy and treatment is not enough for these kids. They need to be connected with community resources and we hope that through this grant we're able to do this kind of service. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. A question to Gladys regarding the school programs. Bob mentioned they have it at the school but they won't take advantage of it. That tells me there's a breakdown. It's duplication of service somewhere, one is not functioning properly. Either they're not getting the message through at the schools ...it's there though, it's available. I get the same impression that high schools have the counseling classes they can be referred to. I don't know the total network of the system, how it actually goes. You say you have the inhouse service that's available. I don't know what the Garvey School District has available, after hours counseling, I don't know all the details. But it appears there's duplication and each organization that comes in, as Mayor McDonald said we have another proposal for the same amount of money, how are they going to be functioning and are they going to ba serving.... I'll be honest with you. My first reaction is that they will serve the Hispanic and you will serve the Asian or oriental and that's the nature of it. But for an overall community, there's federal programs, there's state programs, there's county programs and now we're getting into city programs. It doesn't really seem.... none of them are efficient. It just keeps spreading out. LEE: Let me respond to that. First of all, as far as the school districts that we work with we are not aware that we're duplicating. As a matter of fact Garvey School District is always requesting that we provide a series of these services that in the past we have been able to provide. Now, we can no longer provide because of County restrictions. We work very closely with Marcell Soriano who I guess is going to Cal-State LA now and Rosemead High have asked us for services because they don't have this unique capability so I don't think we're duplicating. TAYLOR: Let me ask you. You made a comment that the County is no longer allowing you to do certain types of counseling? LEE: The County will only allow us to see people inhouse for "direct treatment." TAYLOR: When did they start that? LEE: It's been going on for the last couple of years. TAYLOR: Were you doing it before? LEE: We were doing it before because the County restrictions were not as restrictive, the budget was not as tight. Also, in the beginning when you start a program with any ethic population they don't come to you readily. You need a couple of years of being in the community, doing the outreach. Now, our direct service caseload is very, very high. We get referrals from, I mean we have a long waiting list of people who need help. So, when you have clients who need direct treatment help you cannot justify your staff going out to do early intervention and because the County states your priority is to do direct treatment. TAYLOR: But my reaction is that the County, it goes back to what we have on the gentleman just before you, there's money available and the County is getting money. Our budget cost, basically, for all the staff and general cost is going up 10-150. Not your program but just in general, it's going up, so I believe the County is going to get their money and they're going to get increases and they're demanding more taxes, more increases, they're cutting your services so that money is going to back into their budget someplace. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #7 • 0 LEE: Let me explain. They're not cutting our services. We have a lot of.... TAYLOR: But you're allowed not to do things now. LEE: They haven't increased our base. So, we have the same personnel but our caseload has gone up at least 100%. So, with the same number of people and doubling the work you've got to then prioritize. What's more important, someone who's going to be killing themselves if you don't see them or so depressed they can't get out of bed in the morning. TAYLOR: Your casework doubled in what period of time? LEE: In the last two fiscal years. TAYLOR: What is going to happen in your mind, in the next two fiscal years? LEE: In terms of mental health, right now mental health is facing a $10.6 million budget cut. TAYLOR: Disregarding that. Your caseload went up a 100% in two years. Can you tell me that your caseloads are going to go up 10% in the next two years, 40% in the next two years, or 70% in the next two years? LEE: I can just assume that it's going to go up because the needs are there. TAYLOR: That's my point. I'm sure it's going to go up because this is something... it doesn't say well this year everything is solved and I'm not being facetious with you. All I'm trying to say is it just keeps compounding and compounding. Next year if it goes up 70% your budget's going to have to go up 70%. LEE: That just means that more and more people will be denied services. We'll have to then prioritize more and more. But see the thing is I don't our Center has been very fortunate in that we've had a little bit of United Way money, we have a little bit of AB 90. money, a little bit of child abuse, a whole chunk of mental health, and we're coming to the City for another source of funding and we see it at as a public/private partnership, I mean different resources combining to strengthen what we can do to serve the community. So, I don't see it as us duplicating services I just see it as a marriage, a partnership between different funding sources. TAYLOR: I want to clear up one thing for your benefit. Again, I asked Mr. Robles some of the same general questions. In no way am I picking on any organization or any individual. The point I'm trying to get across is that there's a whole network out there. We're treating symptoms. Everybody's giving a little more money. But go back to the original. What is creating this tremendous growth and expansion of all these programs. So it's no reflection on you or your organization. I want to make that clear. So, that's the reasoning for my questioning and one thing I would ask of you, same thing with all these organizations, is a current budget and the past budget. I'd like those so we can get a better feel of who is doing the funding and why they're cutting it and the percentages of increase and that's just a general comment. BRUESCH: I wanted to go back to what Gary said about duplication of effort with the school districts. There really isn't because I'm talking about personal experience at my school with Asian kids. The way a child in the school that is in need gets services is they've got through the steps. They've got to be referred to a program. The program looks at the referral, prioritizes those needs, takes those kids who need the services the most. The initial contact is made by the program to the homes by phone. If there's no response after three calls the child is put at the bottom of the stack and the next one comes. There's a problem with the Asian homes. Number one is the language difficulty. There are not enough counseling services that ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #8 BRUESCH CONTINUES: have Cantonese speaking, Vietnamese speaking, Cambodian speaking counselors. There's just not enough of them. Secondly, the demands of the program because of servicing so many kids states that the parents have to have a conference either at the school or at some neutral site with the counseling program. Most Asian, non-English speaking families will not do that. So, what is happening to those kids is that they're being put at the bottom of the stack because they can't make that initial contact. What I'm saying is that programs have got to be developed that take this non-contact group and contact the families in a different way. They are not getting services. It is not a duplication of efforts. They plain and simply are not getting service. We had a kid that was a runaway for three years. They contacted him three different counseling programs through the school. None of them made that initial contact: He got put down at the bottom of the stack. Only by physically taking the kid over to the Asian Pacific program finally they got a person to go to the family and say hey this kid is in a real problem area and they got some services. That was before the restrictions were put on the program. So, it is not a duplication of efforts. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. One short comment on it, then. There's a lot of things that happen, Bob. You can pick out one individual case, you can pick out five individual cases. I'm not disputing that there is an incident somewhere or several incidents. A year ago I built a County facility for the mental health treatment. February the 8th, 1989, was the completion date. With extensions we finished that building in June. This is June of 1990. That building has not opened yet. It is sitting, brand new, unoccupied. That's inefficiency. You catch a private business doing that and what happens? They are out of business. All I'm looking for is efficiency and finding out the federal government, the different fundings. That's what upsets me. I physically know this is going on. I built that building. The federal government come in later, the state stepped in, they want TV monitors in all the rooms for the patients. Things that they went through. The State Planning Department, the Fire Marshall, these things happen and I don't like it as a taxpayer. Most taxpayers don't know this. All I'm saying is the efficiency of the organization. McDONALD: Let me make a statement here. I think what we're looking at gentlemen is Intervale provided health services in this community for a number of years for $42,000. Right now, do we want to give Asian Pacific, and I would recommend $21,000, so that we've got $21,000 of priority for Rosemead citizens. That's all we're looking at. We know that, and Gary is perfectly right, every organization, no matter where they are, comes in the next year because they see all this need for services and they're certainly those needs for services are out there. They're only going to provide those services as they prioritize them to the amount of money that they have. We've got to make the determination do we think mental health service here in Rosemead that we've had in the past is important enough to fund in the future. We don't have anybody else available. County is cutting way back as you notice on mental health. So, if we as a City want to participate in providing $21,000 priority to the Asians through Asian Pacific and probably $21,000 through the Family Counseling Service for the Hispanics and hopefully they'll take me when I go off the deep end. Do we want to do that? But this gives us a prioritizement that Rosemead citizens are going to get up to that point a priority and if they can justify that I'm willing to try them for a year. Do I have a recommendation? BRUESCH: I'll so recommend. McDONALD: Any further comment? IMPERIAL: Mr. Mayor. I'd like to see this deferred for the information I requested. McDONALD: Why does it come down to budget day that we ask for this information? We've had this budget for a week, gentlemen. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #9 0 • LEE: And once again, I'd like to underscore. You can talk to the local schools, Garvey School District, I think that would give you a better source of data than the official public record. If you look at the official public record, Asian communities do not need any services. Traditionally, Asian, especially Asian immigrants, underutilize services. So, the general image is that they don't need services which is not true. So, I like to really state that for the record. McDONALD: Mr. Imperial would like to defer it, Mr. Bruesch. BRUESCH: Well, the thing of it is then on all of these then we're going to have to defer because there's really no budgets on any of the programs that have been requested. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. I think it would be appropriate when these new programs come in like this it should be staff policy that they bring in that backup information. Mr. Bruesch knows full well that when we went through the Boys Club that I demanded all that information and it took some time to get it and I guess maybe I should apologize for not coming in and requesting all this from staff. If we put it in the record now maybe that will be done in the future. McDONALD: Okay, what are we asking then of Asian Pacific? IMPERIAL: I want a breakdown and Roberta Trujillo can give us this, of the Hispanic community it would service, a breakdown of the oriental community that would be serviced in this community and the programs they offer and what they've done so far so that I want to see some facts and figures before we go into this. And I want to also make it a point for the record that I think that what we're looking at in the City of Rosemead is funding for this year. If we fund for this year and not to take it for granted it's for next year and the following year because I think that because we're financially fat right now so to speak that that's not always going to be what's going to be happening in Rosemead and we need to especially with the impact in this community we need to be looking at being very careful on where we're going to spend our money in the future. McDONALD: We apologize for not telling you what kind of information we needed here. But do you have that down? TRIPEPI: I have that down, Mr. Mayor. We apologize, as staff. For any new organizations in the future we'll have the past three year's budgets attached. We will tell them that's part of the information that has to go on. McDONALD: We'll defer that and you'll be contacted when you get that information as soon as you can and we'll set another date. LEE: And I'll work with you, Frank, to clarify exactly what information you need next week. END VERBATIM DIALOGUE WILLDAN - TRAFFIC - 01-4510-110, 160 MOTION BY COUNCILMAN TAYLOR, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL that the Traffic Engineering budget be approved for a total of $30,050 (Traffic Engineer - $22,050 and Engineering/Traffic Studies - $8,000). Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #10 s w ROSEMEAD CHAMBER OF COMMERCE - 01-4200-750 MOTION BY COUNCILMAN TAYLOR, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH that the Chamber of Commerce budget be approved in the amount of $29,000. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. FAMILY COUNSELING SERVICE OF WEST SAN GABRIEL VALLEY 01-4200-775 VERBATIM DIALOGUE FOLLOWS: TRIPEPI: Joseph Soto from Family Counseling. Obviously, Mr. Soto is here this morning to present the Family Counseling request for funds. This particular action is probably going to be deferred for reasons that the Council's going to request some additional information and we apologize. Staff could have asked for that and that's one that got by us so we apologize for that so we're going to ask you to provide some budgets, say for the past three years of your operation and I know there's going to be a request for some statistics as to the numbers of kids from Rosemead that you are servicing out of your entire consortium that you serve and I'm sure that you have those figures to breakdown. I know Roberta has mentioned before that this could be targeted out and separated. Perhaps this morning Joe you can answer any specific questions the Council may have without need of providing additional information but at the very least we're going to need again the three years budgets and a breakdown of the percentage of the community that you service from your total budget. McDONALD: Yes, Joe. What we've done in the past is we've funded Ingleside Hospital for mental health services. Sometime last year they went private and decided not to provide those services and so we have two groups that are asking to provide services. One is Asian Pacific Family Center and the other is your group, Family Counseling Services. Both of you are asking for the same amount that Ingleside has had. You're new in the respect of providing health services for us. We don't know what you can do and what you can't do so what they're asking is what will you do for your $42,000? We were kind of thinking of splitting the monies and giving half to you and half to the other organization if we do decide to appropriate those funds. But we'd like to see what you can provide for those services. Not necessarily what you're doing now for everybody else but what's this money going to do for us and where is the priority for Rosemead citizens and how will you show us by us giving you that money that at least you'll use that much money up on our Rosemead citizens. So, that's kind of what we're looking for. IMPERIAL: Mr. Mayor. Joe, I think what I'm looking for is we had $42,000 we're supposed to be getting the proper amount of treatment for the people in the City of Rosemead. Now, that organization doesn't want that business anymore so we're talking about two organizations coming in for $42,000 a piece which is $84,000. When we were getting it for $42,000 before. I hesitated to give any money to the Asian Pacific because they're telling us we want the $42,000 and Mr. McDonald suggested half but I'm not sure that half the people in the community are Asian, they're not. Percentage wise that money should be given out. For instance, if you've got 40% of the population and 15% is Asian then I don't see that you get half and they get half. I think you should have a bigger share because you got more Hispanics you need to deal with. So, that's what I'm after, those kind of figures. What you're going to do and those kind of figures that tell me what's appropriate if we do go with this. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. I'd like Mr. Soto to comment in general the services that they will be providing additional to the Rosemead youth and family than what you're already providing. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page 411 0 0 JOSEPH SOTO: Basically the proposal that my involvement is with the prevention education component. We're planning to expand services that perhaps our agency sees as a need right now coming to the City of Rosemead from the different school districts that we're involved in. For example, Garvey School District has a high service request coming in for that particular Garvey Intermediate School campus that is one that is very interested in having services especially for the Latino population. They made a considerable amount of requests. We have not been able to provide that school with the services necessary simply because we don't have the sufficient amount of staff, we don't have the sufficient amount of funding to provide the services necessary that that particular school is requesting. But that's just one school. We've had different requests from Rosemead High School, various intermediate schools within the Rosemead School District, that are asking for support in terms of prevention, in terms of parenting classes, in terms of support groups for youth, and family education. Now, predominantly most of these schools are Latino and right now we feel that a great percentage of these services that we are providing are very equally distributed within the whole area. However, there is a lack of services in these particular schools and we're trying to expand services further for the specific purpose of prevention education. Dr. Hirsch can expand a little bit more from the clinical aspect how we plan to expand our services with the money you propose to do. TAYLOR: As far as the additional money what programs you have in operation now, what the additional money will buy, the services that will be provided, background information on that. DR. HIRSCH: Are we talking specifically about school services? TAYLOR: Whatever services are going to be provided. DR. HIRSCH: We list a whole series of services in here because we're not certain what you're interested in funding and what you're interested in expanding on. One of our primary proposals is enlisting parents to provide support for parents to deal with some of the disruptions of gangs within their own family structure. We're well aware that through the whole community and through the whole country at this point, gangs are a national problem. What we are focusing on, one of the things that we propose to do is to really enlist the help of the parents in dealing with their own children's gang activity. A very novel kind of concept and as far as we know is not being done anywhere. We work with a lot of these parents who come into our agencies. We also work with a lot of the children in the school systems, themselves. What we found and what we set forth in the proposal is that frequently the parents are held captive within their own houses by their children and they don't know what to do, they don't know how to cope. The alternatives that seem to be open to them are A, either to turn the kids in or B, to evict them from the house. As parents and as a parent myself although my son is not involved in gang activity this is a very difficult kind of alternative to do. What we propose is to form some parent support groups beginning with one, have one of our people consult to that group, and start bringing in resources and start teaching them in a sense how to become effective parents, how to deal, if possible, and not always possible, with the gang members within their own household and then expand outward from there. So that's one of our prime proposals. We also propose once that gets started to begin looking for seed money from other areas. One of things that we've experienced in writing the proposal is that we got it in rather quickly. We haven't had a chance to see where if things are funded from you in the sense that it amounts to seed money and we can go to other grants, other agencies, other things and say this is a project that is now ongoing, we want to expand it. We want to bring in and allocate money from other areas. So, if we have the good fortune to be funded for some of these things, part of our proposal through the whole thing is to look elsewhere for money to augment the funds that we get from you. We also plan to start an ongoing planning process to start working more directly with the residents, the counseling, all of the various agencies and levels to find out more definitively what is needed. In a sense we are coming from our knowledge both from clinic patients., from contact with ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #12 • i HIRSCH CONTINUES: various people in the community, the school systems, and saying these are the things we think you need. These are the things we propose, this being the first of one and we'll discuss the others. But we'd like to augment an ongoing information planning process so that we can offer programs that are really tailor-made to the needs of the City and becoming an integral part of the City. A second proposal that we're setting forth is to begin work with senior citizens. We have contact with a senior gerontologist in Los Angeles who is associated with the Alzheimer's Foundation. We propose to use this consultant to fit in with some of the already existing programs that you have and thus to both provide consultation and again to attempt to get money from the Alzheimer's Foundation. Some of the statistics that we're aware of are that roughly 40%-50o of the dementia and senile psychosis seem to be Alzheimer's related and there's a great deal of money available now for treatment in those areas. So, we propose to bring a senior consultant and to continue working with the programs that have already been set up and to try to use this person, A to get some people in from a new program that has been started at USC, we've had some contact with USC, University of Southern California, they have a very expansive gerontology program. They have interns that they're interested in placing in the community. Our consultant has contact with that and was trained at I think it's the Andrus Gerontology Center and bringing some of those interns in again to work. Our funding in that area is to pay for the consultant and to pay for some of the coordination that goes on. Our third proposal is a resident awareness kind of program. We propose this in terms of writing a column to answer citizen's questions about mental health, family, crisis, domestic violence, those kinds of things that are within the general purview of our agency and thus in one sense making awareness, responding to questions. The second part of the proposal is to contact and try to obtain either some donated or low cost air time on a local radio station, both Spanish language as well as English language. We have some initial contact with radio KALI and again they seem responsive to that. We have to pursue that further. We propose to do some things such as linking programs together. As you know and as Mr. Soto has probably spoken about before I arrived we have a presence already in the schools. We work with teens and alcohol abuse and substance abuse and pregnancy areas. We also in a round about way kind of work with the gangs because a lot of these kids are hooked into the gangs. So, we work with them. We now have a two-year track record of working with these children and bringing them successfully back into a school environment. What we would propose are simple kinds of things on the air, perhaps having teens talk to teens, telling what their experiences were. Peer relationships we've found clinically, have a very heavy impact. Sometimes much heavier than we as adults can have. Sometimes less. But they're a very decisive influence to hear a teenager's experience of what happened to them in a gang relationship, what happened to them in a pregnancy, what happened to them with drug abuse. I have a long track record of working with substance abuse. I was the coordinator for Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health for west Los Angeles for about four years in substance abuse. And so I've worked with teens and all kinds of things. Mr. Soto has extensive experience in doing it. What we feel is exactly what I've said we want to bring these kids in, put them on in a sense where they can disseminate information. In addition to that, we would like to disseminate information about programs that are going in where people can avail themselves of free or low cost services. One of the greatest problems going on is that mental health services have been cut drastically. As you may or may not know County of Los Angeles deals almost entirely now with a chronic homeless population that is in a sense their self-appointed decision. State mental health funding comes and goes. Most people do not have resources to go to and if they do they frequently are short term. They deal with the crisis, put that crisis together, deal with another crisis. What we propose is to put people's awareness that there are services such as available our clinic and other clinics funded by United Way, funded by various local grants and so on so that people can come and utilize these services. We basically as we propose are going to try and raise people's awareness of what their alternatives are, what their resources are and in a sense what happens to them especially at the teenage level, that's where most of our focus would like to be in that area, when they go astray. Sharing ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #13 0 0 HIRSCH CONTINUES: experiences. We propose someone to coordinate these activities, to make the contacts with the media. I will probably be the person if you accept the proposal writing the column and making those kinds of responses. Basically I'm the senior clinician within the agency and I would be the person responding to that. Ministerial support. We would like to hook that in to the other programs that we have in the sense of providing help with counseling, with pre-marital, marital kinds of problems, senior citizen kinds of problems, substance abuse kinds of problems, parenting kinds of problems. Many people go to their ministers rather than to the secular sector to get counseling, to get mental health advice, to get all kinds of information. What we would like to do is work with the already established ministerial group and provide augmented counseling, I'm sorry, augmented consultation to them in the various areas in which we have expertise. Part of our proposal as set forth in the overview says that depending on what is accepted for funding we are going to try and link things together to make the maximum use of our staff time. It's very hard to speak to that budgetarily because we don't know where things are going to go, what's going to be funded, what's not going to be funded. But once we have some kind of picture of what will happen we're going to try and bring things together and use overlapping staff. TAYLOR: A comment I'd like to make on your funding right now. Where do you get most of your funding from? HIRSCH: The bulk of our funding comes from United Way. We're a United Way funded agency. We've been so since 1967. We do some fundraising through our annual dinner. We do some fund-raising through people who contribute. We have just hired a fund developer who we hope will go out and start developing funds, sources of funding within the business community. TAYLOR: What public agencies actually donate? HIRSCH: Public agencies donate? Not in the sense of donate. We have a contract with the Department of Children Services, the County of Los Angeles, Office of Drug Abuse, the office of Alcohol Programs, those are for alcohol and drug prevention. TAYLOR: What is your relationship now with the school districts? How do you function with them? SOTO: What we're doing, we're trying to provide prevention and education services. We have a long standing relationship with a lot of schools within the Rosemead School District. We been providing parenting classes for a long period of time. We been self-esteem building groups within elementary school children. We been providing family education base programs within the community. We've acted as guest speakers at different school districts, made different presentations, all on prevention related topics. So, we've had these type of relationships for a long period of time. What we're trying to do now is expand on our expertise based, for example on family based education, is a very different type of prevention approach compared to some of the existing prevention programs that exist now. At the same time we're trying to tailor the needs of Rosemead. And what we see is we're encouraged to come out and do more family education programs. TAYLOR: How do you specifically help individual children or a family? SOTO: What we try to do is we work for a long period of time. Our programs run for 10-15 weeks. It's not just dessimation (dissemination of information. It's the relationship that you build along with the role modeling of the program staff. So, we've worked with the entire families. We have different components, specialists will work with the children, other specialists will work with the parents, then we come together as a whole and we try to some sort of an activity that will try to enhance family communication, understanding of each other's behaviors and also an education process that will hopefully enhance the whole cohesiveness of the family system. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page 414 i 9 TAYLOR: You have statistics on, I don't want the names of any of them, but specific children and families, how many you've handled in Rosemead? SOTO: Yes, sir. TAYLOR: That's one of the things that I'm going to ask for and I think Mr. Hirsch you weren't here when we made a comment to Mr. Soto about asking for the budgets for the past three years as far appropriations, where the money comes from, the funding. It's basically a new program with the City of Rosemead and we deferred the other proposal before you, the same treatment to get all this information and I'm basically, one of the things I'm looking for is the duplication of services in the sense that we know the federal, state, county and I'm not going to reiterate all my comments but finding out which is the most efficient way and the services have to be provided. No one is disputing that but trying to find out the results of who's providing what seems to be or is the best services. It's so hard to evaluate because as you know this is all psychological and mental and how do the family and the children benefit. You can't go out and say they got three home runs in the last game or they had two traffic tickets or they got four touchdowns. You can't evaluate it that way. HIRSCH: We have some concrete things both in terms of what are statistics and in terms of what I would call war stories that add to the evaluation of it. TAYLOR: What do you mean, war stories? HIRSCH: War stories are what happened to various people who we treated and their successful rehabilitation from the war that occurs in their lives on a daily kind of basis. We've had, in the pregnant teens program, a fourteen year old who has been pregnant twice and has delivered. She is now working successfully as a waitress. She is off welfare. She is supporting herself. She is supporting children. That's a success story. We have a couple of failure stories of children who have been forced out of their home because of the disgrace they felt for the families and basically one we found under a freeway overpass, living there. We helped her to connect with welfare. We helped her connect with a variety of 'things and she disappeared. We don't know what happened to her. TAYLOR: How do you compile those statistics? HIRSCH: We have to, for our contracts, we have to keep statistics on the units of service delivered, the people contacted and so on. That's for payment under those contracts, those are required for the funding. Within our clinic files we keep case records which contain the clinical information and the things that are in that. TAYLOR: I know a certain amount of that information is privileged for the individuals where it's not for public review but I would like to see the war story successes and the rate of failures and such on a number basis. To me that's one of the most important things, it's just that direct to evaluate how efficient the program. Nobody, by any means, is going to have a 80-20 perfect relationship. No organization. That's understood. But we're getting so many proposals and you have to in optimistic when anybody presents a proposal it's the..... what's the best benefit coming out of it but the negative also when you evaluate all of them, the different proposals, we have to have that information and that again is one reason for the deferral of this particular item and as I said the others also have been deferred. HIRSCH: We'd be happy to provide that for you and provide that both in terms of success, failure and the unknowns, the ongoing things. One of the programs that Mr. Soto has is a Magic Circle. SOTO: Magic Circle is a small... the purpose of it is to enhance self-esteem mastering socialization skills and they're small groups, self-esteem building groups, and we spend a period of 15 weeks within the schools and we focus on early prevention children, kindygarten through third. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #15 0 TAYLOR: Within the schools, at the school sites? SOTO: Yes, in the classroom, with the teacher. HIRSCH: The crucial part of this is with kindergarten to third grade children. So, we are going in to begin at a level that will carry through these kids lifetimes. IMPERIAL: Again, Joe, we're talking percentages that we're dealing with from Rosemead. SOTO: Okay. So, percentages specifically. IMPERIAL: Whether it's Rosemead High School or what so we get a clear picture of this. BRUESCH: Just to reiterate what they have been saying and also to corroborate what Gary was saying. One of things that I got out of that Seattle conference, going up there, was the fact that the needs are there because of growth. We have a growth factor especially in this area but most large cities like Gary says are faced with a thousand different needs and a million proposals to get those needs and what a lot of the larger cities have done is plain and simple gone out and hired a consultant to find out what programs are servicing what groups and what needs are being satisfied and what percentage points. Of course our City doesn't have the wherewithal to do that. We're going to have to rely on information given by the organizations to see what the overall picture is. There is some duplication of effort but there are some gaps also and we have to have that picture. We're shooting at the dark if we don't have those numbers. McDONALD: Thank you, Bob. Any further discussion by the council? Okay, we've moved to defer that then until we get that additional information. You'll be contacted when we're going to take a vote on it. Thank you very much for your input this morning. GREATER EL MONTE GIRLS CLUB - 01-4200-720 TRIPEPI: The next item is the proposal from the Greater E1 Monte Girls Club. It's proposing two alternate levels of service, one in the amount of $14,400 and the other in the amount of $22,280. Debra Regan is with us this morning to expand and answer any questions that you may have. They did receive partial funding last year. McDONALD: Debby, why don't you go ahead and tell us what has been going on here in Rosemead? DEBRA REGAN: Right now, we have our two day program and it's Tuesdays and Thursdays and we meet at the Rosemead Methodist Church. We've got an enrollment of 50 girls that come, that are enrolled with us in the program and I'd say on a daily basis, we have between 35-40 that attend our program and we've been very fortunate to get some community support through Linda Montoya. She's come in periodically with the (SANE program. We've had great community support also from the Kiwanettes, from the Kiwanis Club. They've come and helped with tutoring and we've got a very positive response from the parents and they would like to see this program continue on for more than the two days. I'd love to go five but you know but three would be great just to service these kids. BRUESCH: What is the age group? REGAN: The youngest one we have enrolled there is seven and the oldest one is thirteen right now. We get a few kids, the older ones from Muscatel. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. Miss Regan, you mentioned that there are 50 girls registered? REGAN: Yes. TAYLOR: And Tuesdays and Thursdays you have 35.... ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #16 REGAN: Some kids can come one day and some kids come the other. A lot of it is conflict with Catechism classes running on Tuesdays so some of them can only come on Thursdays. TAYLOR: But you're actually saying..... there's a sign sheet from what I understand. REGAN: There's a sign in sheet, right. TAYLOR: And you have 30-35 each.... REGAN: We have about 30-35 that come in. TAYLOR: Each day, then. REGAN: Each Tuesday or Thursday. I've had a great response also from the schools. Mrs. Jacobs from Encinita has been fantastic as far as when I went to recruit at the beginning of the year and assemblies with the kids and stuff so we've had a nice response since Mrs. Donnelly has accepted our program, too. So, we do get a lot of kids from savannah, also. TAYLOR: What time is the facility open? REGAN: I usually get there.... it's about 2:30 p.m. to 5:30 p.m. so it's a three hour. TAYLOR: How much more will this expand over what the current program is? REGAN: Well, what I would like to see more of, if we went longer, I'd like to get a TETRA program in there, involve more like we have in our E1 Monte club since we are having older kids that are becoming interested in it. Then next year we have quite a few that are going to be in junior high and I wanted to incorporate more of the teen training program. TAYLOR: You'd expand the program to, what would that expansion include? REGAN: The teen training, what we do, for instance in E1 Monte is we have a group of teenagers that have been with us for a little while and when they get to be about 12 and 13 we start training them to help with the classes, set up classes, basic job skills. We do a little thing on the side that's like a separate club. You know, meet with them once a month just to kind of give them their own individuality to meet their needs as they're growing. I would like to go longer because I'd like to see....I know there's an interest in these girls in Rosemead to do this program and I'd like to provide it for them. My objective is to keep these kids through high school and to have them after school and to have them do positive things in the community instead of being home by themselves from two to six. McDONALD: What does the TETRA stand for? REGAN: The TEen TRAining Program. McDONALD: Two years ago when we put that teen training program into effect in E1 Monte, just for information, we had the girls try to come up with a name for themselves and they came up with TITS to begin with. It was Teens In Training is what is was and we said NO! So, they came up with this TETRA program but the concept is as far as the young.... once they start in this elementary we found over the years in E1 Monte that the teens wanted something that was specifically for them because they're going through the changes of life and we get them doing all sorts of things in the community and it's really nice. It's like these other programs as you see that they're trying self-esteem, this program also does that and that's one way of doing it and it's worked out real well. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #17 0 • REGAN: We have a positive response. What's nice in the community now is our teens are going out in the community and we're getting people excited about placing them in jobs in E1 Monte so that's we want to offer them something even after high school and something they can come back to. TAYLOR: How can we evaluate the program other than the attendance? REGAN: Anyone's more than welcome to come by the program and see how we run it. In the summer time, E1 Monte, we go 40 hours just to get an idea of.... to see our teens in action because in the summer time we have more classes and the teens each take the responsibility of each class. They all have their specific class that they help through and I'd welcome anybody to come.by and view the program. TAYLOR: I mean as far as evaluating the program, there were three other groups, organizations prior to you and we were trying to get an evaluation process of how successful the program and statistics on the number of families and children that are helped and I really don't know how to evaluate your program other than it's an optimistic one and it encourages the children to participate. What kind of a check point can we have on it? REGAN: Well, if you'd like ...another thing I've done, I try to keep in touch with the parents. I can put out an evaluation to the parents to see their response and send copies to you if you'd like to do that. There's the people in the community that volunteer, I can have them write up an evaluation, also, to get their opinion about the program and the changes, and the effects, positive, that they've seen, too. IMPERIAL: Hard copy, facts and figures, is what I'm looking for. TAYLOR: How does your....I don't have it in front of me or reviewed all the information on your budgeting. Where's all the money come from? REGAN: Basically, there's two different plans that we had. One was Plan A which would be a three day budget and the total budget was $24,000 and we're requesting $14,000 and the rest of the $9,000 would be donated. MCDONALD: Total funding..... TAYLOR: Overall, the organization, not just what you're asking from Rosemead. REGAN: You mean for the whole Rosemead program? TAYLOR: The total program that you're operating, the sources of revenue and where does that come from? TRIPEPI: For example, Family Counseling gets most of its funding from United Way, okay? We're looking overall. REGAN: We get funding through United Way. We get community funding. We get City funding. So, I don't have those exact figures on me right now for the whole program. McDONALD: Last year when we requested the budget because they were funded last year, we get about $70,000 about half the budget, close to half the budget from United Way. We have support of the woman's club over there, the Soroptomists, the Rotary, the Kiwanis, the City gives us in kind, they give us the building and the property and the playgrounds plus $10,000 in cash, too. This program here is an expansion. You asked what the expansion was. It does add another day. It's a three-day program, right? REGAN: Right and we want to go.... there were two of them. We've had such a response from the parents that we'd like to at least go three days a week. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page 418 0 • McDONALD: Last year we had.... it was a partial program last year. We didn't get funded right away because it didn't get started right away and it was about $8,000 or $9,000 that the City funded. BRUESCH: Mr. Chairman. When you're talking about it in terms of effects of programs you want a numerical value. About the only thing you can-do is how many kids are serviced per dollar. There's actually no way to judge the effect of a kid's program because you don't see the effects until four, five, seven, ten, twelve years in the future. We're talking about trying to put a numerical value on attitudinal changes and that's something that the educational sector has been struggling with for a century. How can you measure attitudinal changes? You can't. You look out at a classroom of 32 kids and you've got a master criminal and a genius there somewhere and you don't know which one is which and you measure intelligence and all sort of test scores but that doesn't tell you about the success of the child. It's awful, awful difficult to find out what the effect of any type program is, any type of diversion program, any type of police program, any type of club program has on the attitudes of those children and basically that's what clubs like these are dealing with is attitudinal changes and maybe you can put it into terms of this kid goes to school more often but that doesn't mean that in the future that kid is going to become a good citizen of our community. It's awful hard to judge. REGAN: To me, the success of the program is that the kids come back and they keep asking are you going to be going on in the summer, are you going to be here next year and what are going to do? To me, that's the success of the program and I see the positive response. To me, when they come in and open their books and do their homework and we have the older kids which help tutor them, that to me is success. That makes a valuable program. McDONALD: Another thing I'd like to mention is it is a girls club in the respect that girls are in the club and that's all that's in the club so it specifically works with girls, their attitude changes, their building self-esteem. It's not like it's a part of let's say, Family Counseling Services, working with mental health. We don't have a specific thing that we diagnose the kids and say you've got a health problem. But any time there is a problem with a child it's referred. We refer them to other services or refer to their parents that they need some sort of service. But what this is is more of a prevention program that gives a place for young girls, after school, to go to work with their peer groups, to be able to raise themselves, what do they call that, the whole group itself, the self.... REGAN: It's a self-esteem building. It's a group self-structure. MCDONALD: Right, where they become responsible for as she says, they put them into groups, they have to make their own decisions and if they make a bad decision they have to suffer the consequences from their peers and it's really something that provides them with something that the families don't and Ithink we know that throughout all the communities that less and less is coming from the parents because everything is sky high as far as cost of livings are concerned. We have single family parents, they have to work and the kids just don't have as much attention as they've had in the past. So, this is more of a club atmosphere, a group building program and like she says, actually this has more kids in it at this moment than E1 Monte does. Soon as we opened the doors there were more kids in it. So, it's something that has been very successful over there for this last year and the only way that we measure it is that the kids come back and we have kids from seven years old and as they grow in the club, we start the TETRA program which is the teen program so it helps them to adjust in that area and keeps them out of trouble. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. My comments and I want to be fair to each one of you that have given a proposal I've asked this of all the others also how to evaluate the program and the gentleman that was just here prior to you, there's not a page on here but in your proposal it says problems statement community need. We're hearing the same thing over and over. We've got the teenage pregnancies here, the school dropout ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #19 TAYLOR CONTINUES: rate, child abuse, drug abuse, gang violence, outreach and they're all good intentions, every one of them. (Tape turned over) the aid for the same intention and it's needed in different areas of the City but there is a definite overlap and I don't expect the kids from Rosemead to go down to Garvey or Garvey come up to Rosemead or over to Muscatel or Garvey School. But I don't know that's one reason I ask the funding. I don't know just how they're interlinked. So far, from what I've heard, your funding doesn't come from governmental agencies, as such. REGAN: No. The majority of our funding is through United Way and thank God we have a lot of community support. TAYLOR: Again, I don't question the intent of yourself or anyone else working in the program. The crisis is there. I mean even the schools themselves, as far as they talk about the children that graduate and their ability even when they get out. This is just a common fact in every school district there's a certain failure ratio and there's no way to evaluate to well, why did they all fail or why did most of them succeed. You have to make that judgement call and it's the same thing with this particular organization trying to evaluate and it really gets down as I told the other gentleman it's kind of a psychological thing or a mental thing. You can't evaluate when a kid goes out feeling good at the end of the day or the ones that don't show up that feel lousy during the day. It's extremely hard to validate. Not what you're success ratio is or your failure it's just kind of a hit and miss thing either the community continues to be a harmonious community or it's disrupted with whether it's graffiti or gangs. It's just so hard to evaluate the results. That's why I'm trying to find something that well, we can point to a positive aspect of your particular program and I have to agree you can get a certain amount of satisfaction and I get a tremendous amount of satisfaction when you're seeing kids and young people that are having a good time in constructive activities but there are also a lot of those available. Your organization provides one, Parks & Recreation has another program, many youth groups, probably a dozen of them in the City. REGAN: What is nice about our program though because we deal exclusively with girls is and as they grow up and they hit puberty, girls are more comfortable around other girls and I've seen this over and over again. When you have the girls and the boys together they segregate, anyway. And they get giggly and when it comes to certain issues or any type of questions that they wish to ask they're inhibited because of the boys being there. What's nice about our program is we are girls and we can offer a positive service to girls and they can be themselves. You know, they do things that they would never do if it was as if it was a boys and girls club. They'd be off giggling in a corner. One thing that I do like about our program is we can help with the self-esteem. We can tell these girls there are hundred of options out there for you. And they sit down and they talk to us, they talk among themselves. They ask questions and I can positively guarantee that if it was in a different situation these questions wouldn't be asked and they would be more inhibited. BRUESCH: Mr. Mayor. I want to corroborate that. Even at the programs in the Boys & Girls Club most of the activities are segregated activities. They have sports for boys; sports for girls. A teen club for girls; a teen club for boys. They all go participate in the programs but the activities within the programs is for the specific reasons that she states, the kids most in need are from ten to fourteen. That age group, maturity-wise, the girls are much more mature than the boys and they don't want to deal with the little kid stuff that the boys deal with a lot of the times and they do have specific needs and those needs are met better by having in their sex grouping. That isn't speaking as a male chauvinist. It's just reality. REGAN: It's true. MCDONALD: Okay. They're asking for an "A" program or a "B" program. Does anybody want to make a recommendation on either of those or ADJ CC 6-2-90 - , Page.. #20..., TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. In all honesty I'll say that I'm not going to vote on it at this time because we deferred the other three proposals and again I think that they all have good ideas and good concepts and programs and again, I want to reiterate that it's nothing personal with the organization at all. I just feel very uncomfortable. Next year, I'm going to give you the RYA, which is the baseball organization we have. We have the Rosemead Little League in operation. We have the American Soccer Association and there are other groups. Maybe they're fortunate And we have the Rosemead Rebels who were funded this year, partially on a one-time request and I'll say right now, that I will vote no on that project when it comes back because they made a commitment, it was a one-time.... I dread to see these organizations who have a community support behind them you mentioned the organizations that are helping you.... there just seems to be when there's a hole or a leak some place organizations tend to come around, well, we will get more government funding and I dread to see that. I respect all the organizations but this going in from so many organizations, how do we draw the line? Yours is one of the better ones of the three so far because it isn't government funding coming through. United Way, it's been what I'd like to see as true community support not a government agency, just a place to draw money from. And these other organizations, they deal with several hundred. Three hundred to five hundred children and they're positive programs. But I respect them for the integrity and the ability that they have to make that organization work. Their internal policing that they have, the monitoring, the discipline. It's so hard for me to say okay well I'm going to give in here and then they come in and say we need the money, too. We would like to show you what we can do. And pretty soon they start relying on government agencies and then you see exactly what's happening with the LA mental, the County. They say we've got to cut these funds. We don't have enough to keep putting it out. The gentleman just before you said that there is an excess now of funding available for Alzheimer's disease. That money's available for that program now but we cut the others and we'll try this program for a while. It's extremely frustrating for me to appropriate these monies. Not because of what your intent is but because everybody's entitled to start drawing from it. So, I can't vote on your program even though I agree with what you're doing and we've turned down the others, we deferred those. We are becoming so selective. We either give it to all fifteen of them because of their positive aspect or we have to screen it out. So, I feel frustrated not to say, gee I support you a hundred percent and I want to do it but I can't do that fairly. IMPERIAL: Request we defer this as the rest and ask for some information. MCDONALD: You have some specific information that you'd like? IMPERIAL: Well, she volunteered whatever information she could get, Mr. Mayor, from parents and what have you. She's already made a statement that she could get this information. I'd like to see what she's got in hard copy. REGAN: No problem. McDONALD: Let me make a comment here. I think the Council's the one that has to make decisions on things. Gary doesn't think that when we give money back to the community that it's part of the community. That taxpayer's money is the community money. It certainly is not ours. We just happen to be the group that makes the determination that Rosemead needs that service. If Rosemead needs that service, yes we're a governmental agency but we're collecting those taxes because of the population that we have in the City and that's community money. So, when we support that we're supporting it as a community priority that we as the elected officials see as a need and a service in this community. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. I agree with your comment, one hundred percent. No dispute. It's not our money. It's the taxpayer's money and we have to administer it equally and fairly and sometimes discriminatory to which organizations get it. No question. I said I agree with one ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #21 TAYLOR CONTINUES: hundred percent and I do. It is taxpayer's money. But there has to be that discretion and decision. We can't please everybody. We all know that. I don't dispute any organization but it's just a mushrooming effect. Why is it that the federal government and the state government, no new taxes, we're not going to increase taxes in California. And yet they're clamoring, we've got to do it, we've got to do it. And then they're turning it around, they're closing the trauma centers. We can't afford these, that's their reasoning. We've got to close these trauma centers. They're too expensive. They're losing millions of dollars every year, all of them. Now, the mental health people are cutting back which is a bigger government agency by any standard. The Los Angeles mental health facilities, they're closing them. And they're coming to the local communities, and again this is not these organizations I'm questioning, it's just this social policy that's going on. It's going to get much worse. As I asked the lady before is it going to increase 10%, 400, 70% for her next year's program when she said over the last two years, it's increased hundred percent. And I don't have the answer. So, I agree with your comment. It's a hundred percent taxpayer's money. McDONALD: Irregardless, though. As these services are cut from the federal government or cut from the state government, cut from the county government, we have a certain amount of monies there. If we believe these services should be provided to our people here in Rosemead we have to take up a certain amount of the slack because it's their money and they're not getting the service. So, we have to set the priority. When we don't have the money, we can't spend it. When we've got the money at least we could provide the services that are available out there. It's no good just to keep it in the bank and saying well, maybe something's going to happen. While we've got the money we ought to provide the services. IMPERIAL: I think you're absolutely right when you say, set priorities. And that's what we're trying to do and that's the reason we're asking for this information. McDONALD: Give her a little more specifics on the information. IMPERIAL: Okay. We just talked about this. She said she had no hard copy on anything. McDONALD: What do mean hard copy? For what? IMPERIAL: I'm talking about facts and figures, Mr. Mayor. McDONALD: Fact and figures on what? That we've prevented two pregnancies because we talked to them? IMPERIAL: Did you ask me a question? Or did you ask it so you can answer it? McDONALD: That's what I'm asking. She needs something specific. IMPERIAL: When I say specific, I'm saying she said she had no information on everything she's done, her success rate and what have you; she would get some letters and what have you. Right now, we have nothing, okay? I'm not casting any stones but I can tell you I'm the world championship skier but you're going to want to see some credentials. What I'm saying in reality is I want to see some facts and figures so we can determine that like we're going to do everybody else in all fairness, and set our priorities. McDONALD: I'm not arguing that. We're going to defer that but she needs something specific to give you the information. Now, we can make statistics say anything they want. We can say we have thirty girls there, we prevented all of them from getting pregnant so our pregnant prevention program has worked elaborately. IMPERIAL: Am I allowed to ask for addresses of the people who have participated? ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #22 0 0 REGAN: Sure. I have all the enrollment papers. IMPERIAL: All right. Give me a list of the kids. McDONALD: Okay, that's good. IMPERIAL: Letters from the parents, and what have you. This is what you suggested, anyhow. Did you understand this? REGAN: Yes, this is fine. IMPERIAL: Okay, then I don't think she has a problem understanding me, Mr. Mayor, it's right here. McDONALD: No, there's not a misunderstanding because I'm a staff member in a City and when I ask for information or somebody asks me for information, I want to know exactly what they want otherwise I'm either too much leg work or not enough. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. A comment just to settle that one issue. I think that we've hassled these things in the past that you know and I know ...maybe we don't make it a specific point and stressful of it but each time these come up we're talking basically the same thing as far as backup information. Each time it comes up. And they present a proposal but staff again for whatever reason oversight, you name it. They know that we most of the time get into these detailed discussions on it to justify and verify what we're doing. So, we need that information and whatever we can get. McDONALD: I just was wondering because they were funded last year, okay, like the Rosemead Chamber of Commerce last year, and like Willdan Associates last year and I saw the proposals from them and there wasn't any backup information so what I wanted to get her is a list of things that she could explicitly get for you that you see that you needed to make a determination, yeah or nay on their funding. TAYLOR: On the chamber, they presented a 100% copy of what their budget is, listed the whole thing in this proposal and it's been an ongoing thing for what, fifteen, twenty years, Frank? As far as the Chamber being involved? And Willdan being our.... TRIPEPI: Nine or ten. Mr. Mayor. I was going to say the staff is well aware of the information that has been requested and we'll put it in a format so that you can at least do apples and apples and I'll get with Debra and work out or somebody on staff will. We know what you're looking for. REGAN: When would like this information? TRIPEPI: Next week. We can get together with you. We'll work something out. BRUESCH: Mr. Mayor. I think that the Council is asking for a policy to be established that when proposals are made that A, B, C, D, E, F be given to the Council as backup material each time. We should develop a little checklist for each of these organizations to do so. One thing. There's two comments on that type of checklist. Number one is I don't think we can logically ask for what is the effect your program has on the local population because again what I said before you're dealing with a affective domain, you're dealing with attitudinal changes. The only thing you can say..... TRIPEPI: Mr. Bruesch. I think we.... what we understand that. What we're looking for, we're looking for budgets, we're looking for where the funding comes from, the total organization. Secondly, we want percentages of the population that you serve for this City since we're going to be funding part of the program. We understand that. BRUESCH: One thing I do want put on there is the amount charged to each participant, Mr. Mayor. I want the amount charged as membership fees to each participant and the percentage of the budget that comes from admission fees or whatever you call them. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #23 0 • TAYLOR: That would be all of these organizations. BRUESCH: All of them. McDONALD: Okay, so that's deferred. TAYLOR: Mr. Mayor. This is something that has become kind of a new source of funding for organizations. We had the Boys Club come in, then we had the Girls Club. Now, we've got a couple of more. In all honesty, and we also had the Rebels come in, I see that there's ten to fifteen organizations in the future that are entitled to request the money. I would ask, and I'm going to go deeper into these fundings to try to get a correlation of why this is coming about, but in fairness to these people that sit here I'd like the comments on these organizations and they can all get a copy of the Minutes, verbatim so they understand where I'm coming from as an Agency and you gentlemen had comments, also. But I don't want any of them to feel slighted that we're choosing favoritism. So, if there's no objection I'd like that in the Minutes, their comments so that they're treated fairly. MCDONALD: There's got to be discrimination because we're the ones who make it.... TAYLOR: True, but they'll understand why. McDONALD: Right. Because there are some that we can't fund when they come in and there's some we can fund. IMPERIAL: I prefer to call it setting priorities instead of discrimination. TAYLOR: Good word. McDONALD: Setting priorities is discriminating. END OF VERBATIM DIALOGUE A twenty-minute recess was called at this time and the meeting was reconvened accordingly. WE-TIP - 01-4200-760 MOTION BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN TAYLOR that the Council appropriate $3,260 for fiscal year 1990-91. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. WEST SAN GABRIEL VALLEY JUVENILE DIVERSION PROJECT - 01-4200-770 MOTION BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN TAYLOR that the Council appropriate $47,200 for fiscal year 1990-91. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. II. CONSENT CALENDAR Account numbers 4120-010, 4200, and 4780 were removed for discussion. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #24 • E Councilman Taylor requested a full breakdown for account number 4110-190 to explain the 75% increase in the annuity fund; verified that account number 4300 for law enforcement was an estimate only; and asked about 4350, the dues for the Area "D" membership; MOTION BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL, SECOND BY MAYOR McDONALD that the accounts not removed for discussion be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: McDonald, No: Taylor Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None Bruesch, Imperial The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. Councilman Taylor stated that there were several accounts and that he had questioned a few of them but that he was opposed to the salary increases as a policy concept regarding account numbers 4700, 4740, 4750, 4800, 4810, 4820, 4830, and 4850 and requested that account number 4800-180, the sick leave buy.back, be removed from the Parks & Recreation administrative budget and moved to the City Administrative Department. Mr. McDonald requested that the amounts be reflected in each account affected. 4120-010 - CITY CLERK Councilman Bruesch asked why this account had not always been shared with the Redevelopment Agency. Frank G. Tripepi, City Manager, stated that this had been an oversight and was based on the actions of the previous City Clerk. MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH, SECOND BY MAYOR McDONALD that Account 4120-010 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. 4200 - COMMUNITY PROMOTIONS Councilman Bruesch requested a memo regarding Accounts 4200-110, -120, -130, and -140 relating to the City Newsletter, regarding what steps were being taken to obtain a contract for these services. Mr. Tripepi stated that several letters of interest had been received from people who provide this service and that a formal request for proposal is being prepared for the Council to review. Mr. Bruesch requested a copy of the proposal as soon as it has been prepared. MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH, SECOND BY MAYOR McDONALD that Account 4200, less the accounts previously deferred, be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. 4780 - SOLID WASTE Councilman Bruesch noted that the waste subsidy was approaching 7% of the total budget and speculated that the subsidy next year would be 10%. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page 425 It was noted that the trash subsidy should be ending with the current contract's expiration next year. Councilman Bruesch was concerned that funds should be set aside now for any consultant work that may be required in order to comply with AB 939. Mr. Tripepi noted that any necessary fees could be taken from the appropriated reserve at such time when the monies may be needed. MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH, SECOND BY MAYOR MCDONALD that Account 4800 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and'so ordered. Councilman Imperial questioned Account 4700-012, Code Enforcement, and asked if this indicated a new position in this department. Mr. Tripepi stated that there would be only the two current positions, one split through the Redevelopment Agency and one split through the Community Development Block Grant program. III. CONSIDERATION OF REMAINING ACCOUNTS - CAPITAL OUTLAY 4120-910 - City Clerk MOTION BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH that Account 4120-910 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. 4130-910, 920 - FINANCE This request is for the purchase, installation and necessary training for an in-house computer system and the elimination of the need for using a data processing company. MOTION BY MAYOR McDONALD, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL that Account 4130-910, 920 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. Councilman Bruesch requested the amount that would be needed to renew the maintenance agreement next year. 4240-920 - CITY GARAGE For the replacement of a vehicle, Unit 2, consisting of $9,000 from the City and $9,000 from the Redevelopment Agency. MOTION BY COUNCILMAN TAYLOR, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL that Account 4240-920 be approved. Vote resulted: ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #26 • • Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. 4500 ALL ACCOUNTS - CONSTRUCTION, STREETS & HIGHWAYS Councilman Taylor asked the ratio for the storm drain and the signal at Encinita/Lower Azusa - 4500-963. Alfonso Rodgriguez, City Engineer, stated the signal would be approximately $80,000. MOTION BY COUNCILMAN TAYLOR, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL that Account 4500 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. 4720-910 - ENGINEERING MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL that Account 4720-910 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. 4800-850, 900 - PARRS ADMINISTRATION MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL that Account 4800-850, 900 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. 4810-860, 870, 900 - PARRS MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL that Account 4810-860, 870, and 900 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. 4820-820, 860, 870 - RECREATION MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH, SECOND BY MAYOR McDONALD that Account 4820-820, 860, and 870 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #27 4830-900, 930, 940 - AQUATICS MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN TAYLOR that Account 4830-900, 930 and 940 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. 4840-850 - RECREATION FEE & CHARGE MOTION BY COUNCILMAN TAYLOR, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH that Account 4840-850 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. 4880 - ALL ACCOUNTS - PARR PROJECTS Councilman Taylor asked for about the repairs that had been done at Rosemead Pool and Garvey Pool. Mr. Tripepi stated that the repair history on both pools for the past ten years be given to the Council. Councilman Bruesch requested a labeled diagram of the surge pit system. MOTION BY COUNCILMAN TAYLOR; SECOND BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH that Account 4880 be approved. Vote resulted: Aye: Taylor, McDonald, Bruesch, Imperial No: None Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. IV. CONSIDERATION OF PERSONNEL RECOP94ENDATIONS Frank G. Tripepi, City Manager, recommended a 5.5% cost of living adjustment (COLA) with a 0-5e merit increase, based on the individual's performance and work effort, for all City employees. Mayor McDonald requested that the COLA and the merit increase be considered as two separate items. MOTION BY COUNCILMAN TAYLOR that the total increase be limited to 6% for both items and this motion died for lack of a second. MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH that the COLA be limited to 5.0% and this motion died for lack of a second. MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH, SECOND BY MAYOR McDONALD that the Council approve the 5.5% COLA. Vote resulted: Aye: McDonald, Bruesch No: Taylor, Imperial Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None MOTION BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH that the COLA be approved in the amount of 5.6% for fiscal year 1990-91. Vote resulted: ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page 428 Aye: McDonald, Bruesch Imperial No: Taylor Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. MOTION BY COUNCILMAN IMPERIAL, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN BRUESCH that the Council approve a 0-5% merit increase as recommended by the City Manager. Vote resulted: Aye: McDonald, Bruesch Imperial No: Taylor Absent: DeCocker Abstain: None The Mayor declared said motion duly carried and so ordered. It was noted that this included the City Manager. Councilman Taylor stated that his vote reflected no dissatisfaction with staff but that he had a philosophical difference as far as what the cost should be and it was no reflection on any individual. Mayor McDonald ascertained that the four items that had been deferred would be placed on a regular meeting agenda when the information requested had been obtained. There being no further action to be taken at this time, the meeting was adjourned at 12:45 p.m. to June 12, 1990, at 8:00 p.m. Respectfully submitted: APPROVED: i CAYty Clerk MAYOR ADJ CC 6-2-90 Page #29