Loading...
CC - Item 4D - Temple City Blvd Resurfacing Award of Contract g E m r f ROSEMEAD CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT• o5a TO: THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL FROM: BILL R. MANIS, CITY MANAGER 7)y,� DATE: JULY 12, 2016 SUBJECT: TEMPLE CITY BOULEVARD RESURFACING PROJECT FROM INTERSTATE 10 ( I 10) FREEWAY TO GUESS STREET AWARD OF CONTRACT SUMMARY As a part of the City's Fiscal Year 2015-16 Capital Improvement Program, the City Council approved the "Temple City Blvd Resurfacing/ I-10 Freeway to Guess Street" Project. This project includes the grinding of existing pavement and the reconstruction of the roadway with new asphalt concrete, replacement of damaged sidewalk, striping and appurtenances. This project is funded through Prop C funds. Staff Recommendation It is recommended that the City Council: 1. Approve the plans and specifications for the Temple City Boulevard Resurfacing Project from 110 Freeway to Guess Street; and 2. Authorize the City Manager to enter into a contract with All American Asphalt in the amount of $ 343,145.00. In addition, authorize an amount of $34,315.00 (approximately 10%) as a contingency to cover the cost of unforeseen construction expenses. DISCUSSION The Temple City Boulevard Resurfacing Project was included in the Fiscal Year 2015- 16 Capital Improvement Program with funding through Prop C funds. The scope of work for this project includes the grinding of existing pavement and Asphalt Concrete overlay of the roadway with new asphalt concrete along Temple City Boulevard from 1-10 Freeway to Guess Street. Additional work includes the reconstruction of damaged sidewalk, curb and gutter, striping improvements, and appurtenances. Temple City Boulevard is a busy arterial that provide access to 1-10 Freeway and vicinities. According to the City's Pavement Management Program, which was updated in 2016, these segments of roadway have Pavement Conditions Index (PCI) scores ITEM NO. 4.D City Council Meeting July 12,2016 Page 2 of 3 between 41 and 59, which classify the conditions of these roadways as "Poor'. The average of this section of Temple City Boulevard is 55. A Notice Inviting Bids was published in local newspapers and trade publications on June 23rtl and 30th, 2016. Sealed bids were received by the Office of the City Clerk until 10:30 a.m. on Wednesday, July 6, 2016. At 11:00 a.m. on July 6, 2016, the City Clerk publicly opened and read five (5) sealed bids with the following result: Rank Bidder Location Total Base Bid Total Base Amount & Alternate No. 1 Bid Price 1 All American Asphalt Corona, CA $ 232,646.50 $ 343,145.00 2 Excel Paving Company Long Beach, CA $ 271,234.00 $ 390,204.75 3 Sully Miller Contracting Brea, CA $ 262,805.00 $ 393,184.50 4 Hardy & Harper, Inc. Santa Ana, CA $ 287,000.00 $ 411,000.00 5 EC Construction So. El Monte, CA $ 308,089.80 $ 451,289.90 Staff has reviewed the bid documents for completeness and has reviewed the contractors' backgrounds and recent projects for competency. Staff recommends the award of contract to the lowest bidder; All American Asphalt. All American Asphalt is a well-regarded general engineering contractor that has completed major road reconstruction projects for many public agencies in Southern California. All American Asphalt has worked on the City of Rosemead Projects previously; one of these projects was the Residential Street Resurfacing Project in 2012. As a result of the low bid prices and available funding in the budget, it is recommended that the City Council award Alternate Bid Item No. 1 in addition to the Base Bid. Alternate Bid Item No. 1 includes the complete rehabilitation of Loftus Drive, from Temple City Boulevard to Easterly City Limit, which consists of the removal and replacement of 2" of asphalt, the repair and replacement of damaged sidewalk, the installation of new roadway striping, and the planting of new trees in the parkway. The rehabilitation project will provide the residents with a new roadway surface rather than one with substantial patches from previous repairs. FINANCIAL REVIEW The Temple City Boulevard Resurfacing/I 10 Freeway to Guess Street is included in the FY 2015-16 Capital Improvement Program. The project has a budget of $475,000 from Prop C Funds. Prop C funds are local return funds from Los Angeles County Sales Tax for transportation projects. City Council Meeting July 12,2016 Page 3 of 3 ESTIMATED PROJECT COST Description Amount Base Bid Amount including Alternate $ 343,145 Construction Contingencies $ 34,315 Total Contract Work $ 377,460 Contract Administration $ 40,000 (Caltrans Permit, Inspection and Staff Time) Geotechnical Engineering Services $ 10,000 (Soil Testing and Material Testing) Total Project Cost $ 427,460 ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW This project is categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Section 15301 (C) of the CEQA Implementing Guidelines. PUBLIC NOTICE PROCESS This item has been noticed through the regular agenda notification process. Prepared By: Submitted By: .9 I•, ,6.41A-Le/&, afael M. Fajardo, P.E. Curtis Cannon Acting Public Works Director Interim Assistant City Manager Attachments: A. Plans and Specifications (Available in the City Clerk's Office) B. Bid Analysis C. Bid of All American Asphalt PUBLIC WORKS SERVICE DEPARTMENT/ENGINEERING DIVISION 7/62016 CITY OF ROSEMEAD TEMPLE CITY BOULEVARD RESURFACING PROJECT PROJECT NUMBER, 21024 B D ANALYSIS BID SUBMITTAL; JULY 6 2015 AT 1100 AM. ALL AMERICAN ASPHALT #1 BABE&D PRICE F ITEM DESCRIPTION CITY I UNIT UNIT PRICE. TOTAL CLEARING AND GRUBBING PER PLANS/SPECS. 1.001 LS 790050 5 7.900 50 DISPOSAL OF WASTE MATERIALS 1001 LS 360000 $ 3600 00 COLD MILL 2"EXISTING PAVEMENT 12570.00 1 SF 010 S 12,57000 CONSTRUCT 15"THICK PAVEMENT OVERLAY 1 140.00' TONS 7300 5 0120 D3 CONSTRUCT ID"ASPHALTIC LEVELING COURSE DI 760 00 j TONS 7400 5 5624000 REMOVE.DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT 4"PCC SIDEWALK 88000 SF 860 $ 7 568 D0 REMOVE,DISPOSE CONSTRUCT F'CURB 124"GUTTER 2000 LF 110.D0 $ 2200 D3 REMOVE.DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT PCC CURB RA MPS 300 EA 3800.00 $ 11400.00 REMOVE,DISPOSE CONSTRUCT PCC DRIVEWAY APPROACES 22500 SF 1400 $ 3150.00 1 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT PCC CROSS GUTTER 78000 SF 2100 $ 1638.00 1 ADJUST SEWER MANHOLE TO GRADE 900 EA 703001$ 632700 ADJUST WATER AND GAS VALVES TO GRADE 1100 EA 56900 $ 6.259 00 1 INSTALL SURVEY WELL MONUMENT(CITY FURNISHED) 08 EA 1, 03300 $ 1,732 00 i INSTALL TRAFFIC STRIPING SIGNAL LOOPS.AND PAVEMENT MARKERS 100 LS 8,20000 $ 8200.00 1 TRAFFIC CONTROL PLAN PREPARED BY REGISTERED TRAFFIC ENGINEER 1 D LS 590000 5 590000 TOTAL BASE BID PRICE 3 232,640.50 ALTERNATE I LOFTUS DRIVE-FROM TEMPLE CITY BLVD TO ECL 16 COLD MILL 2'EXISTING PAVEMENT 45.275 00 SF 0.10 $ 4,52750 17 CONSTRUCT 15'THICK PAVEMENT OVERLAY 410.00 TONS 7300 $ 29,930 00 18 CONSTRUCT 10"ASPHALTIC LEVELING COURSE DI 27400 TONS 7400 $ 20,276 00 19 REMOVE,DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT 4"PCC SIDEWALK 69000 SF 860 $ 5934.00 20 REMOVE,DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT PCC CURB RAMPS 700 EA 368.00 $ 26.600 00 21 REMOVE,DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT PCC DRIVEWAY APPROACES 21000 SF 14,00 $ 2.940 00 22 REMOVE,DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT 4INCHES THICK PAVEMENT 4400 TONS 190.00 $ 8,360 00 23 CONSTRUCT 6-INCHES THICK OMB 648 TONS 1600 $ _ 1.024 00 24 ADJUST SEWER MANHOLE TO GRADE 100 EA 70300 $ 70300 - 25 ADJUST WATER AND GAS VALVES TO GRADE 200 EA 56900 $ 1,13000 26 INSTALL SURVEY WELL MONUMENT(CITY FURNISHED) 200 EA 43300 $ 06600 27 INSTALL TRAFFIC STRIPING.SIGNAL LOOPS,AND PAVEMENT MARKERS 100 LS 8,200 00 $ 820000 TOTAL ALTERNATE BID PRICE $ 110.49$.50 TOTAL BASE AND ALTERNATE BID f 341145,00 PAGE PUBLIC WORKS SERVICE DEPARTMENT/ENGINEERING DIVISION 7/&20,6 EXCEL PAVING COMPANY #2 BASE B O PR CE 1 I L 1 I ITEM ".DESCRIPTION - CITY • UNIT I UNIT PRICE TOTAL 1 CLEARING AND GRUBBING PER PLANS/SPECS 10 LS 2200.00 $ 220.0.00 1. 2 DISPOSAL OF WASTE MATERIALS 100 LS 5500.00 $ 550.00 3 COLD MILL 2"EXISTING PAVEMENT 1257000 SF 0.17 $ 21.369 00 4 CONSTRUCT 15'THICK PAVEMENT OVERLAY 1.14000 TONS 001$ 93480.00 5 CONSTRUCT I 0'ASPHALTIC LEVELING COURSE DI 7600 TONS 7300{$ 5548000 6 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT 4.PCC SIDEWALK 8800 SF 090 $ ]83200 7 REMOVE,DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT B"CURB/24"GUTTER 20 D0 LF 7375 $ 1.47500 8 REMOVE.DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT PCC CURB RAMPS 30 EA 320001$ 000.0 A APPROACES... ......... 9 REMOVE.DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT PCC CROSS GU GUTTER 7800 SF 210 $ 63800 10 ADJUST DISPOSE.WMANH OLE TO GRAD ROBS GVTTER ]B0.00 SF 020 $ 163100 11 ADJUST SEWER MANHOLE TO GRADE 900 EA 7030 $ 6.318 0 12 ADJUST WATER AND GAS VALVES TO GRADE I 1100 EA 48000 $ 528000 13 INSTALL SURVEY WELL MG,SIGNAL FURNISHED) 400 EA 480.00 $ 1920.00 14 INSTALL TRAFFIC STRIPING,SIGNAL LOOPS.AND TERED MENT MARKERS. 1 0 LS 1]90.00 $ 1]00.'0.00 15 TRAFFIC CONTROL PLAN PREPARED BY REGISTERED TRAFFIC ENGINEER 100 LS 4900.00 $ 450.00 TOTAL BASE BID PRICE $ 271.234.00 ALTERNATE LOFTUS DRIVE-FROM TEMPLE CITY BLVD TO ECL 16 COLD MILL 2"EXISTING PAVEMENT 45.275 00 SF 0.19 $ 860225 17 CONSTRUCT IS"THICK PAVEMENT OVERLAY 4100 TONS 8200 $ 3362000 18 CONSTRUCT 1.0"ASPHALTIC LEVELING COURSE DI 27400 TONS 730 $ 202 000 19 REMOVE.DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT P"PDC SIDEWALK 690.00 SF I 975 $ 672750 20 REMOVE.DISPOSE CONSTRUCT PCC CURB RAMPS 700 EA t 3,400.00 $ 23800.0 21 REMOVE DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT PCC DRIVEWAY APPROACES 21000 SF 1330 $ 2,79300 22 REMOVE DISPOSE CONSTRUCT 4-INCHES THICK PAVEMENT 4400 TONS 171.00 $ 75240 23 CONSTRUCT 6-INCHES THICK CMB 64.00 TONS 710 $ 4,54400 24 ADJUST SEWER MANHOLE TO GRADE 100 EA 8700 $ 87000 25 ADJUST WATER AND GAS VALVES TO GRADE - 200 EA 6220 $ 1,2440 26 INSTALL SURVEY WELL MONUMENT(CITY FURNISHED) 200 EA 6220 $ 1 244 00 27 INSTALL TRAFFIC STRIPING,SIGNAL LOOPS.AND PAVEMENT MARKERS. 100 LS 60D00 S 800.0 TOTAL ALTERNATE BID PRICE $ 115.970.75 TOTAL BASE AND ALTERNATE BID $ 350,204.75 PAGE 2 PUBLIC WORKS SERVICE DEPARTMEN➢ENGINEERING(MORON I/6/2015 SULLY MILLER CONTRACTING COMPANY #3 RASF BID PRICE I I I I ITEM -DESCRIPTION QTY . UNIT UNIT PRICE- TOTAL 1 CLEARING AND GRUBBING PER PLANS/SPECS. 1.00 LS 1960000 S 1960000 - 2 DISPOSAL OF WASTE MATERIALS 100 L$ 20 0000 $ 2.00000 3 COLO MILL T EXISTING PAVEMENT 125.700 00 SF 010 5 22626.00 4 CONSTRUCT 1 S"THICK kC LEVELING OVERLAY 1,14003 TONS 6.03 $ 98.04003 5 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CI ASPHALTIC LEVELING COURSE 01 700 00 TONS ]800 $ 5928000 6 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT 4"PCC SIDEWALK 880.00 SF 600 $ 7 04000 7 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT P00 CURB/2A' CU I RAMPS GUTTER 2300 EF 300.00 5 20.0000 ................... B REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT PCC LURE RAMPS 36 EA 430000 $ 12900.00 9 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT PCC DRIVEWAY APPROACES 225.00 SF 11.00 $ 247500 10 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT PCC CROSS GUTTER 780 00 SF 1300 $ 10,14000 11 ADJUST SEWER MANHOLE TO GRADE 900 EA 1.10000 $ 990000 12 ADJUST WATER AND GAS VALVES TO GRADE 1100 EA 64.00 $ ]04.00 13 INSTALL SURVEY WELL MONUMENT(CITY FURNISHED) 4DO EA 100000 $ S60000 14 INSTALL TRAFFIC STRIPING.SIGNAL LOOPS.AND PAVEMENT MARKERS. 103 LS 65006 $ 850000 15 TRAFFIC CONTROL PLAN PREPARED BY REGISTERED TRAFFIC ENGINEER 100 LS 100000 5 100000 TOTAL BASE BID PRICE $ 262805.00 ALTERNATE I l LOFTUS DRIVE.FROM TEMPLE CITY BLVD TO EDL 16 COLO MILL 2"EXISTING PAVEMENT 45 275 SF 018 $. 8,149.50 17 CONSTRUCT I5"THICK PAVEMENT OVERLAY 41000 TONS 8600 $ 3526000 18 'CONSTRUCT 10"ASPHALTIC LEVELING COURSE DI 27400 TONS ]8.00 $ 2137200 19 I REMOVE.DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT 4"PCC SIDEWALK 69000 SF 000 $ 5520 D0 20 !REMOVE.DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT P00 CURB RAMPS ]00 EA 4300.00 $ 30,100.00 21 I REMOVE.DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT PCC DRIVEWAY APPROACES 21000 SF 1100 $ 2,31000 22 ;REMOVE,DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT 4-INCHES THICK PAVEMENT 4400 TONS 28500 $ 1254000 23 TCONSTRUCT&INCHES THICK BMB 6400 TONS 183.00 $ 6400.00 24 ADJUST SEWER MANHOLE TO GRADE 100 EA 110.00 $ 1.16.00 25 'ADJUST WATER AND GAS VALVES TO GRADE 200 EA 64.00 $ 12800 26 INSTALL SURVEY WELL MONUMENT(CITY FURNISHED) 200 EA 1.40000 $ 2800.00 27 INSTALL TRAFFIC STRIPING.SIGNAL LOOPS,AND PAVEMENT MARKERS 100 LS 4700.00 $ 470000 TOTAL ALTERNATE BID PRICE $ 130,379.50 I.TOTAL BASE AND ALTERNATE BID $ 393,104.50 PAGE 3 PUBLIC WORKS SERVICE DEPARTMENT/ENGINEERING DIVISION 7/6/2016 HARDY 6 HARPER.INC N4 RASE RID PRIC.F I ITEM DESCRIPTION On UNIT UNIT PRICE TOTAL 1 CLEARING AND GRUBBING PER PLANS/SPECS 100 LS 38.000 D9 S _30.000.D3 2 DISPOSAL OF WASTE MATERIALS 100 LS 3,000 00 $ 3000.00 3 COLD MILL T EXISTING PAVEMENT 125700.09 SF 0.18 $ 2262600 ~ 4 CONSTRUCT 15"THICK PAVEMENT OVERLAY 1,14000 TONS 7777 S 88,05780 5 CONSTRUCT 1 0"ASPHALTIC LEVELING COURSE 01 760.D3 TONS 6959 $ 52888.40 6 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT 4"FCC SIDEWALK B¢0.00 SF 800 S 7.04000 7 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT 8"CURB(24"GUTTER 2000 LF 10000 S 2000.6/ B REMOVE.DISPOSE CONSTRUCT PCC CURB RAMPS 300 EA 380000 5 1140000 9 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT FCC DRIVEWAY APPROACES 22500 SF 1100 5 247500 10 REMOVE,DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT PCC CROSS GUTTER 70000 SF 1600 $ 12480 D9 1 ADJUST SEWER MANHOLE TO GRADE 900 EA 1CU0.00 $ 9000.00 12 ADJUST WATER AND GAS VALVES TO GRADE 1100 EA 10."009 $ 11 CC0.00 13 INSTALL SURVEY WELL MONUMENT(CITY FURNISHED) 400 EA 1500.00 $ 6000.00 14 INSTALL TRAFFIC STRIPING SIGNAL L00PS.AND PAVEMENT MARKERS. 1OD LS 15432.80 $ 1543280 15 TRAFFIC CONTROL PLAN PREPARED BY REGISTERED TRAFFIC ENGINEER. 1 DO LS 5,00000 $ 5.00000 TOTAL BASE BID PRICE $ 287,000.00 — ALTERNATE I _ LOFTUS DRIVE-FROM TEMPLE CITY BLVD TO ECL 16 COLD MILL 2"EXISTING PAVEMENT 45.275 00 SF 0.18 5 8,149 50 17 CONSTRUCT 15"THICK PAVEMENT OVERLAY 41000 TONS 7777 $ 31.85 70 1B CONSTRUCT 1 0"ASPHALTIC LEVELING COURSE DI 27000 TONS 69.69 5 19095.06 19 REMOVE DISPOSE CONSTRUCT P"PCC SIDEWALK 69000 SF 800 $ 5,520 00 20 REMOVE.DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT FCC CURB RAMPS 700 EA 3,80000 $ 26,600 00 21 REMOVE DIS POSE.CONSTRUCT FCC DRIVEWAY APPROACES 210.00 SF 1100 $ 3310.00 22 REMOVE.DIS POSE.CONSTRUCT/INCHES THICK PAVEMENT 4400 TONS 150 D9 $ 6.600 00 23 CONSTRUCT 6-INCHES THICK CMS 61.00 TONS 100 00 5 6400.00 24 ADJUST SEWER MANHOLE TO GRADE 100 EA 1090.00 $ 1000 00 25 ADJUST WATER AND GAS VALVES TO GRADE 200 EA 10.^0.00 $ 2,000.00 26 INSTALL SURVEY WELL MONUMENT(CITY FURNISHED) 200 EA 1 500 00 $ 3,000 00 27 INSTALL TRAFFIC STRIPING.SIGNAL LOOPS,AND PAVEMENT MARKERS 100 LS 11 A3974 $ 11,439 74 TOTAL ALTERNATE BID PRICE J_ $ 124,000.00 — 4 TOTAL BASE AND ALTERNATE BID '$ 411,000,00 PAGE4 PUBLIC WORKS SERVICE DEPARTMENT/ENGINEERING DIVISION 7/62018 EC CONSTRUCTION X5 BASF 04D PRICE I I I I 1 ITEM DESCRIPTOR On UNIT : UNIT PRICE TOTAL CLEARING AND GRUBBING PER-PLANS/SPECS. 100 LS 3000000 $ 30000 DO DISPOSAL OF WASTE MATERIALS 1001 LS 2000.00 $ 2000.00 COLD MILL 2"EXISTING PAVEMENT 125700001 SF 032 $ 40.224 00 CONSTRUCT 1.5"THICK PAVEMENT OVERLAY 1.14000 TONS 65.12 $ 97,03680 CONSTRUCT I O"ASPHALTIC LEVELING COURSE DI 76000 TONS 7980 $ 60,54600 REMOVE,DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT 4"PCC SIDEWALK 88000 SF 1345 $ 11836.00 REMOVE.DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT B"CURB 124"GUTTER 2000 LF 100.00 $ 2,000.00 REMOVE,DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT PCC CURB RAMPS 300 EA 3,500.00 $ _ 10.500 00 REMOVE.DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT PCC DRIVEWAY AP PROACES 22500 SF 14.00 $ 3,15000 I REMOVE.DISPOSE.CONSTRUCT PCC CROSS GUTTER 78000 SF 1600 $ 12,480.00 I ADJUST SEWER MANHOLE TO GRADE 900 EA 1090.00 $ 9.810 00 1 {ADJUST WATER AND GAS VALVES TO GRADE 1100 EA 10000 S 1,10000 1 !INSTALL SURVEY WELL MONUMENT(CITY FURNISHED) 400 EA 930.00 $ 3.720 00 I !INSTALL TRAFFIC STRIPING,SIGNAL LOOPS.AND PAVEMENT MARKERS. 100 LS 17585.00 5 17,50500 I TRAFFIC CONTROL PLAN PREPARED BY REGISTERED TRAFFIC ENGINEER 100 LS 60x3.00 $ 6.000 00 TOTAL BASE BID PRICE 5 30.089.80 ALTERNATE I _ LOFTUS DRIVE-FROM TEMPLE CITY BLVD TO ECL 16 COLD MILL 2"EXISTING PAVEMENT 459500 SF 0.16 $ 724400 17 CONSTRUCT 15"THICK PAVEMENT OVERLAY 41000 TONS 9130 $ 37.43300 18 CONSTRUCT 10"ASPHALTIC LEVELING COURSE DI 27400 TONS 99.28 5 24,46272 19 REMOVE.DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT 4'PCC SIDEWALK 69000 SF 1345 $ 9.280 50 20 REMOVE,DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT PCC CURB RAMPS 700 EA 3,500.00 $ 24,50D 00 21 REMOVE.DIS POSE,CONSTRUCT PCC DRIVEWAY APPROACES _ ) 21000 SF 1400 $ 294000 22 REMOVE,DISPOSE,CONSTRUCT 4-INCHES THICK PAVEMENT 4400 TONS 409.09 5 17,999 96 C23 CONSTRUCT 6-INCHES THICK CMB _ 6400 TONS 13578 $ 8.689 92 24 ADJUST SEWER MANHOLE TO GRADE 100 EA 1.100 00 $ 1.100 00 25 ADJUST WATER AND GAS VALVES TO GRADE 200 EA 10000 $ 20000 26 INSTALL SURVEY WELL MONUMENT(CITY FURNISHED) 200 EA 925.00 $ 1,850 00 27 INSTALL TRAFFIC STRIPING,SIGNAL LOOPS.AND PAVEMENT MARKERS. I 1 00 LS 750.00 $ 7.50000 TOTAL ALTERNATE MD PRICE $ 143,200.10 TOTAL BASE AND ALTERNATE BID 1 $ 451,269.90 PAGE5